The Big Swap: Why Industries are Offering Debt for a Slice of Ownership

Introduction: Practical Guidance for Auditors and Accountants

Auditors and accountants are on the front lines of interpreting and applying evolving accounting guidance. ASU 2024-04 represents a significant update. The rule expands the scope of induced conversions to include more complex debt instruments, particularly those involving hybrid cash-equity settlements. This paper focuses on providing practical, industry-specific applications of ASU 2024-04 to help accounting professionals understand how to assess, document, and audit such transactions across different sectors. To read more click here.

Summary of Key Changes in ASU 2024-04

ASU 2024-04 updates the guidance on how to account for induced conversions of convertible debt instruments. The key changes are:

• Scope Expansion: Applies to instruments settled in cash, equity, or a combination.

• Form and Amount Test: The inducement offer must match the form (e.g., cash vs. shares) and amount of consideration originally issuable.

• Fair Value Reference Date: Comparison must use the fair value of shares on the date the offer is accepted, even if pricing references VWAP or future prices.

• VWAP Flexibility: VWAP adjustments alone don’t trigger extinguishment; judgment is required.

• Non-Convertible Instruments: If a substantive conversion feature existed at issuance and offer acceptance, induced conversion treatment may apply.

• One-Year Lookback Rule: If the debt was modified (not substantially) in the past year, inducement terms must be compared to those from one year prior.

Industry-Specific Applications

remove

add

Technology & Startups

Why do they offer convertible debt?

Technology and startup companies frequently use convertible debt, such as convertible notes and SAFEs, to secure early-stage funding without triggering immediate equity dilution or setting a definitive valuation. This flexible approach allows founders to defer valuation negotiations until a priced equity round while incentivizing investors with the potential for discounted future equity.

ASU Implications

ASU 2024-04 increases scrutiny around inducement deals offered near liquidity events like IPOs or funding rounds. Auditors must confirm that inducement offers preserve the original consideration's form and amount, such as the balance between cash and equity. Deals offering warrants or a modified conversion formula may no longer qualify as induced conversions and could trigger extinguishment accounting.

Benefits

For auditors, the clarity provided by ASU 2024-04 helps standardize treatment of startup financing structures, reducing the chance of misstatement. It also encourages startups to maintain clean, auditable capitalization tables and minimizes valuation disputes at critical financial reporting stages.

Considerations

Startups often operate with lean finance teams and minimal documentation. Auditors need to be proactive in obtaining fair value analyses, board resolutions, and historical deal terms. Early engagement in financing decisions can help ensure proper accounting from the outset.

remove

add

Financial Services & Banks

Why do they offer convertible debt?

Why do they offer convertible debt? Banks and financial institutions issue convertible subordinated debt as part of their capital structure, often to satisfy Tier 1 or Tier 2 regulatory capital requirements under Basel III. These instruments offer fixed returns and conversion features that align with investor and regulatory needs, and provide balance sheet flexibility.

ASU Implications ASU 2024-04 affects how inducement offers related to regulatory capital instruments are evaluated. If the inducement modifies the cash-equity balance or includes new features, it could be reclassified as a debt extinguishment rather than an induced conversion. This reclassification can have implications for reported earnings and regulatory ratios.

Benefits Companies benefit from increased transparency and consistency in treatment of hybrid debt instruments. The update aligns better with how capital instruments are assessed under regulatory frameworks, supporting clearer internal and external reporting.

Considerations Accountants and auditors must watch for mismatches between financial reporting under GAAP and capital treatment under regulatory rules. Clear documentation is required to support that a conversion remains within induced conversion guidance and doesn't trigger unexpected accounting outcomes or capital deductions.

remove

add

Biotech & Pharmaceuticals

Why do they offer convertible debt?

Biotech firms commonly issue convertible debt as bridge financing between development phases, especially when traditional financing is limited due to the pre-revenue nature of the business. These instruments often convert based on specific milestones, such as clinical trial success or FDA approval, aligning investor returns with business performance.

ASU Implications

ASU 2024-04 introduces stricter criteria for inducements tied to strategic events. For example, if a company offers conversion sweeteners such as additional shares or removes pricing caps around the time of a milestone, the transaction must still meet the form-and-amount preservation test or risk being accounted for as an extinguishment.

Benefits

Auditors now have a more concrete framework to assess complex deal structures often used in biotech financing. The rule reinforces sound valuation practices and helps reduce aggressive inducement structuring that might otherwise bypass proper accounting.

Considerations

Companies should expect heavy involvement in fair value determinations and milestone timing documentation. Any inducement made close to a significant clinical event should be evaluated with heightened scrutiny, including management intent, board communications, and investor responses.

remove

add

Airlines & Transportation

Why do they offer convertible debt?

Airlines and transportation companies relied heavily on convertible debt during the COVID-19 pandemic to maintain liquidity amid revenue disruptions. These instruments were often modified multiple times to manage solvency, avoid default, or respond to government support conditions.

ASU Implications

ASU 2024-04 is especially relevant for this sector, as the one-year lookback rule applies to instruments modified in stages. If inducement offers differ from original terms in form or value, and the instrument was modified in the last year, it may no longer qualify for induced conversion accounting.

Benefits

The update provides a framework for evaluating complex, time-staggered debt modifications. Accountants and auditors gain a basis for aligning accounting treatment with real-world restructuring scenarios, improving investor understanding and preventing financial reporting surprises.

Considerations

Companies must build a clear timeline of all modifications and ensure that each inducement offer is assessed based on terms from one year prior. Coordination with legal and restructuring advisors is essential to understanding intent and ensuring proper disclosure.

Conclusion: What This Means for Practice

ASU 2024-04 requires professional judgment and thorough documentation. It is not enough to rely on standard templates. Auditors and accountants must understand how terms have evolved, evaluate the fair value of new inducement offers, and ensure consistency in treatment. Industry context matters, and careful analysis of each case is key to preventing misstatement and audit issues. This guidance should serve as a roadmap for applying ASU 2024-04 with clarity and compliance.

Sources

Accounting Standards Update 2024-04—Debt—Debt with Conversion and Other Options (Subtopic 470-20): I

Ey-equity-capital-markets-convertible-market-update.pdf

The Role of Convertible Bonds in the Tech Industry's Growth - FasterCapital

The Financial Potential of Convertible Notes in the Pharmaceutical Sector - MedCity News

Tech companies cash in on ‘frothy’ stock rally with convertible bond sales

Footnotes

This is some text inside of a div block.

This is some text inside of a div block.

Elizabeth Hall

Lillian Vaughn

February 24, 2026